Thursday, August 27, 2015

2015 NFL Preview: South




AFC SOUTH 
Indianapolis Colts
Half Full:
Indianapolis has improved every year since adding Andrew Luck, and this year they take the final step. Luck has one of the most dangerous groups of weapons in the league, with star receivers TY Hilton and Andre Johnson bolstered by intriguing rookies Phillip Dorsett and Duron Carter. And with the return of Robert Mathis, they will have a pass rush element to their defense that was missing last year. This team made it to the AFC Championship Game, and they only improved over the offseason. With uncertainties dotting the rest of the AFC, they deserve to be considered a Super Bowl favorite.

Half Empty:
Indianapolis’s offense is flashy, but the real reason they’ve fallen short the past few years is their defense, a side of the ball they did very little to improve. They have a couple of good players in Mathis and Vontae Davis, but the rest of this side of the ball varies from mediocre to terrible. Ben Roethlisberger torched them for 522 yards and 6 TDs last year. The Patriots run all over them whenever they get a chance. Andrew Luck is very good, but this defense will continue to hold them back from taking the next step once they reach the playoffs.

Player To Watch: Duron Carter, WR
The first time I heard of Carter was when he committed to play at Ohio State in 2009. Since then he’s spent time with Coffeyville Community College, Alabama, Florida Atlantic, the Minnesota Vikings (training camp only), and the Montreal Alouettes. He hasn’t managed to stay in one place long, but the problem has never been talent. People keep giving him new chances because of his talent, and if he finally has his head on straight, he could turn into a starting caliber NFL receiver. Of course, there’s still a chance he could end up being cut before the season. With a player like Carter, anything is possible.

Houston Texans
Half Full:
Houston has arguably the best player in the league in JJ Watt, and this year they may have finally surrounded him with capable talent. Vince Wilfork is still capable of contributing despite his advanced age, and if Jadeveon Clowney is healthy, he can be a dynamic pass rusher from the opposite side. Add that to a developing star on offense in DeAndre Hopkins and a solid core of overall talent, and this is a team that can push for the playoffs, and possibly even the division.

Half Empty:
Watt is great, but we saw two years ago that he isn’t enough to carry a team to a successful season on his own. With Arian Foster out indefinitely, their offense looks close to barren. They’ve lost Andre Johnson, they have no reliable option at quarterback, and even with Hopkins this could turn out to be one of the worst offenses in the NFL. It probably won’t be that bad, but even so I could see this team struggling to score points and possibly ending up with a top ten draft pick.

Player To Watch: Rahim Moore, S
The Texans are a team built on the back of JJ Watt, and there aren’t a lot of good players flying under the radar. Duane Brown and Arian Foster have been borderline stars for years. DeAndre Hopkins is following the track you’d expect from a first round pick. Jadeveon Clowney is or isn’t something, and everyone is watching to figure this out. To find a player truly worth attention, I have to go for their free agent signing from the Broncos. Moore is still stung by his failure to knock Joe Flacco’s heave out of the sky three years ago, and this one play has colored the development of an otherwise stellar young player. In Denver he was buried behind a team of veteran stars, but in Houston he finally has a chance to emerge as a foundational piece for a defense.

Jacksonville Jaguars
Half Full:
Jacksonville has loaded up on young talent over the past few drafts, and this looks like a year they could all break out. Blake Bortles struggled through a lot of last year, but he also showed intriguing flashes as both a passer and a rusher. Surrounded by developing young receivers like Allen Hurns, Marqise Lee, and Allen Robinson, he has a chance to lead a true breakout on offense. They are still relying on a lot of young players, and they aren’t in a position to make the playoffs this year. But a .500 record isn’t out of the question, and this could be the season that finally begins to pull them out of their tailspin.

Half Empty:
Young talent is just talent until it actually does something, and so far, very few players on the Jaguars roster have actually done anything. Their offensive line is still a disaster, Bortles needs to make massive improvements in mechanics and decision making, and their defense will struggle to improve after losing first round pick Dante Fowler. There are reasons to be hopeful here, but not for 2015, another season that will see them finish with a top five draft pick.

Player To Watch: Allen Robinson, WR
The Jaguars have a lot of intriguing young receivers, but none have done as much to impress as Robinson. A big, physical target who dominated at Penn State, he had a strong rookie season that was completely ignored due to the performance of the other rookie receivers in the league, the general incompetence of the Jaguars, and an injury that sidelined him down the stretch. But he played well enough to establish himself as the leading candidate for the number one receiver slot, and if he can take another step he can make life a lot easier for their developing quarterback.

Tennessee Titans
Half Full:
Tennessee has intriguing pieces on defense, and this year they are finally in position to put it together. It seems like every year around this time we expect Derrick Morgan to break out, but this year will be different, thanks to the presence of Brian Orakpo on the other side. The two of them will combine with Jurrell Casey to make up one of the league’s most dangerous fronts. A massive defensive improvement is well within the realm of possibility, and if their offense can pull together around Marcus Mariota, this team can push for a playoff spot.

Half Empty:
That final piece is the big question. Mariota is talented, and I expect him to find success long term, but his transition to the NFL may not go smoothly. A great deal depends on how Ken Whisenhunt will utilize him, not necessarily the most promising of circumstances. Whisenhunt can be a bit stubborn when it comes to his scheme, and I can see him trying to force Mariota into a rigid, pocket passing system, leading to a disaster of a rookie season and a total collapse of the team.

Player To Watch: Bishop Sankey, RB
Reports out of Tennessee suggest that Sankey has fallen out of favor and could quickly lose most of his carries to rookie David Cobb. This isn’t surprising considering his struggles last season, but I still think there’s reason to be hopeful about this second year player. Sankey was mismanaged during his rookie season, forced into an offense that didn’t fit his talents behind a line that gave him no help. Sankey isn’t a feature back, but he can be very useful when given the ball in space, an opportunity he could see plenty if Wisenhunt is clever enough to use Mariota in a read option scheme. Under these conditions Sankey is the perfect complement to the rookie quarterback, and he could very easily have a surprise breakout campaign.

NFC SOUTH
Carolina Panthers
Half Full:
Carolina has made the playoffs the past two years thanks to a young core that will only continue to improve. Cam Newton’s abilities on the ground and in the air make him one of the most underrated quarterbacks in the league, and they only need him to make an occasional play to support a loaded defense. With Luke Keuchly, Kawaan Short, and Star Lotulelei holding down the middle of the field, athletes like Thomas Davis will be free to fly to the ball, creating a unit explosive enough to carry them into the postseason again.

Half Empty:
Carolina’s biggest weaknesses the past two years have been offensive line and wide receiver, and they didn’t really address either in the draft. Newton is phenomenally talented, but he can’t carry the team while standing behind Byron Bell and throwing to Ted Ginn. Kelvin Benjamin is a bit overrated as a player, but you can’t overstate his importance to this team. They were mediocre last year who made the playoffs thanks to a wretched division. They won’t be as lucky this year and could easily wind up with a top ten pick.

Player To Watch: Shaq Thompson, LB
I’m trying to stay away from talking any more about first round picks, but Thompson is just too interesting to ignore. He is a relatively unique player, either an undersized linebacker with great coverage instincts or an oversized safety who will dominate against the run. If he gets on the field for Carolina, it will be very intriguing to see how they use him, considering they already have two of the best coverage linebackers in the league in Keuchly and Davis. Thompson is raw, but if he can figure things out, he can be a devastating addition to an already top notch defense.

New Orleans Saints
Half Full:
Last season was a disaster for the Saints, one I certainly didn’t see coming. But their failure doesn’t change the fact that this is an incredibly talented team who can easily run away with a weak division. Drew Brees is still one of the best quarterbacks in the NFL, Safeties Kenny Vaccaro and Jairus Byrd are due to bounce back after a disappointing first season together, and they are finally in position to have a quality running game to support their offense. This team wasn’t as bad as they looked last year, and they don’t have to improve much to make the playoffs again.

Half Empty:
New Orleans spent their offseason with a series of moves that screamed desperation and a need to rebuild. They traded away Jimmy Graham and Kenny Stills. They drafted players who offer more down the road than as immediate contributors. This is a team going through a great deal of turnover, and that instability hardly inspires confidence. Their defense is an uncertainty as always, but for the first time in a while we don’t know what to expect from their offense. A total collapse is not out of the question.

Player To Watch: CJ Spiller, RB
A former top ten pick who has become a mostly anonymous NFL player, Spiller has the potential to become a truly invaluable part of this roster. He had his moments in Buffalo, but they could never figure out how to use his unique skillset. In New Orleans he finally has a coach creative enough to put him in a position to succeed and a quarterback who understands how to use a running back in the passing game. He isn’t as shifty as Reggie Bush or Darren Sproles, but he can find a way to fill that role in this offense.

Atlanta Falcons
Half Full:
The Falcons have been loaded on star power for several years, but they’ve fallen short because the back end of their roster hasn’t been up to NFL standards. For the past couple years they’ve struggled to improve their depth, and they may have finally built a quality structure around stars like Matt Ryan and Julio Jones. Players like Adrian Clayborn and Jon Asamoah won’t carry a team, but they can be crucial pieces to help others do so. They don’t have enough for a deep run, but in a division as weak as the NFC South, they could easily run away with the title.

Half Empty:
Atlanta has worked hard to improve the depth of their team, but they still haven’t done enough. Bringing in low priced veterans can lead to great bargains, but it can also load up a roster with a bunch of unwanted disappointments, like former first rounders Clayborn and Tyson Jackson who never lived up to expectations in their old homes. The Falcons are betting that they can get more from these players than their original teams, but if these players remain who we think they are—borderline starters forced into primary roles—Atlanta will bear a great deal of resemblance to the disappointing team they’ve been over the past two seasons.

Player To Watch: Jon Asamoah, G
Asamoah quietly played a major role in Kansas City’s playoff appearance two years ago, stabilizing an offensive line that had been in flux for years. He was expected to do the same thing when he signed with the Falcons, but injuries robbed him of any hope for a successful first year in Atlanta. Fortunately, he is fully healthy going into his second year with the team, and their need for him is as critical as ever. His presence could give them the boost they need to turn this from a good offense into one of the top five in the league.

Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Half Full:
Even the worst teams have pieces to like, but the pieces on Tampa Bay are up there with any in the league. Gerald McCoy is the best defensive tackle in the league when he’s healthy. Lavonte David is somehow still underrated. Mike Evans and Vincent Jackson form a dangerous duo of towers on the outside. With these kind of pieces, the only thing they were missing was a star quarterback, and they may have found it in Jameis Winston. Winston is a football genius with an arm to match his mind, and he has the potential to burst onto the scene in the NFL much as he did in college. In a division as weak as this one, he could be enough to lead the Buccaneers to the playoffs.

Half Empty:
Stars are great, but they need some capable talent around them, and there is no evidence that Tampa Bay has these quality players to fill out their roster. Their defense has been terrible for years despite the presence of McCoy and David. Jackson and Evans are clearly below the top tier of receivers. And Winston is a quarterback prone to mistakes, the sort of mistakes that could lead to a poor start to the season and another year drafting in the top ten for Tampa Bay.

Player To Watch: Alterraun Verner, CB
Verner was a big time free agent acquisition a year ago, but after a disappointing season he’s been mostly forgotten about. Many are willing to dismiss his stellar 2013 season as a fluke, but the talent he showed was too much to be just a flash in the pan. His skills are perfect in Lovey Smith’s (possibly outdated) defensive scheme, and he can be the piece on the back end to complement their two superstars in the front seven.

Thursday, August 20, 2015

2015 NFL Preview: East



It’s a couple days later than I originally intended, but I guess I’d better get started with my NFL season preview. I’m going to start by going team by team to get a brief look at where they’re at and where I think they’re going. Any specific predictions are a bit absurd, but it is possible to see a range of possibilities for teams, from a best case scenario to a worst case scenario. So for each of the teams I’m going to list a “Half Full” prediction and a “Half Empty” prediction. For each team I’ve also listed a player to watch, someone under the radar who could play a major role in their fortune this season.

NFC EAST

Dallas Cowboys
Half Full:
Dallas’s offense carried them to a surprising 12-4 record last season, and they won’t miss any beats this year. Their running game was built around the success of their offensive line, and even with DeMarco Murray gone they can keep things rolling. Rookies Randy Gregory and Byron Jones give them the boost they need on the defensive side of the ball, and they run away with the division and put themselves in Super Bowl contention.

Half Empty:
The Cowboys are precariously top heavy, and this will come back to hurt them this year. Tony Romo has struggled to stay healthy for years now, and if he goes down again this year they will not be able to put the entire burden of their offense on the running game, not with Joseph Randle and Darren McFadden as their primary options. They’ve added young talent on their defense, but young talent doesn’t always lead to results. There’s enough talent on this team that they won’t completely fall apart, but they could find themselves on the outside of the playoffs at the season’s end.

Player to Watch: Joseph Randle, RB
The bigger name running back on the Cowboys is former top five pick McFadden, but based on everything they’ve done in the NFL (and McFadden’s injury history) I expect Randle will end up being their primary runner. He averaged 6.7 yards per carry in limited time last year, and he’ll be put in a great position to succeed behind the best run blocking offensive line in the NFL. As good as Romo and Bryant are, they can’t shoulder the burden of an entire offense. Dallas succeeded last year because of their balance on offense, and Randle is their best hope of finding that again this season.

Philadelphia Eagles
Half Full:
Chip Kelly has had success as a coach on every level, and at this point it’s hard not to give him the benefit of the doubt. He’s reshaped his receiving corps with young talent like Jordan Matthews and Nelson Agholor, players who fit his style much more than Jeremy Maclin or DeSean Jackson. The true overhaul has come on defense, where offseason pickups Byron Maxwell and Kiko Alonso join stellar young players like Mychal Kendricks and Fletcher Cox to give the Eagles the best defense in the division, enough to carry them into the playoffs.

Half Empty:
No team has had more turnover this season than the Eagles, and at a number of positions they clearly downgraded. DeMarco Murray isn’t as good as LeSean McCoy. The loss of Evan Mathis will hurt an offensive line that struggled with consistency last year. And worst of all, their quarterback situation is completely unresolved, with two options who have both been at best average during their careers. Philadelphia’s offseason rebuild could prove to be a complete disaster, landing them in the top five picks in the draft for the second time in three years.

Player to Watch: Jordan Matthews, WR
Chip Kelly fell in love with Matthews prior to the 2014 Draft, even wanting to reach to take him in the first round. Instead he fell to them in the second, and he had a solid rookie season overshadowed by the performances of other rookie receivers. He spent most of last year playing in the slot, but at 6’3” and 205 pounds, he doesn’t fit the traditional profile of a slot receiver. With Jeremy Maclin gone to Kansas City, it would make sense to give Matthews more reps on the outside. But Kelly is far from a traditional coach, and it will be fascinating to see how he utilizes Matthews.

New York Giants
Half Full:
The Giants offense could be very good. With Victor Cruz coming back to join Odell Beckham, they finally have the potential to give Eli Manning an elite receiving corps. Their running backs and offensive line will hold them back from being a top five offense in the league, but they can do enough damage in the air to make up for the holes elsewhere in their roster, enough to snag a Wild Card or possibly even the division.

Half Empty:
Beckham was great during his rookie year, but he wasn’t enough to carry them to the playoffs, and this team has made very few changes during the offseason. Their offensive line is still struggling with injuries, and there is no guarantee that Cruz will be back to his normal self. On the defensive side of the ball they have only two or three high quality players, perhaps even fewer if Jason Pierre-Paul’s offseason injury causes serious problems. This team won’t bottom out entirely, but they could be on the way to another noncompetitive season.

Player to Watch: Johnathan Hankins, DT
A second round pick in 2013, Hankins has quietly been one of the best players to come out of his class. The mediocrity around him prevents many from seeing how good he is, but last season he was arguably among the top ten defensive tackles in the league. If Jason Pierre-Paul can recover from what happened to him this offseason, the Giants can start on the road back to what they had a few years ago, a dominant defensive line that allowed them to shield their vulnerabilities on the back end.

Washington Redskins
Half Full:
I may be among the minority in this, but I’m not ready to give up on Robert Griffin III. He was too good his rookie year to be a complete bust, and he’s in the best position to succeed he’s ever been in. He has a pair of talented receivers in DeSean Jackson and Pierre Garcon, one of the most underrated running backs in the league in Alfred Morris, and an offensive line that will be healthy after struggling last season. Griffin is the key to their offense, and if he can reach his previous highs, he can lift this team into the fringe of playoff contention.

Half Empty:
Washington’s ceiling isn’t particularly high, but their floor is as low as it can possibly get. Griffin has regressed significantly since his rookie year, and they didn’t make any significant improvements on either side of the ball. First round pick Brandon Scherff will struggle playing guard for the first time in his life, and their defense is still devoid of talent everywhere outside of Ryan Kerrigan. This team sacrificed a huge number of draft picks to get Griffin, and if he doesn’t work out, they’re probably stuck rebuilding for another three seasons.

Player to Watch: Jordan Reed, TE
There isn’t a lot to like on this roster. I originally wrote about Niles Paul, but he has since gone down with a season ending injury. So I’ll instead focus on his backup, the talented but unreliable Reed. Jackson and Garcon can stretch the field deep, but the Redskins are in need of someone to open up the passing game between the numbers, a role they will lean on their tight ends for. Griffin can’t always rely on his legs when pressure comes his way, and he will need a weapon like Reed to take the pressure off of him.

AFC EAST
New England Patriots
Half Full:
They are the defending Super Bowl champions, so their upside is pretty clear. Bill Belichick has shown consistent ability to take whatever talent he has into the postseason, and if Tom Brady ends up being available for all sixteen games, they should have no problem winning the division once again. Their front seven on defense is filled with scary young talent like Chandler Jones, Donta Hightower, and Jamie Collins, more than enough to make up for their losses on the back end. New England is in a great position to defend their title, and it is hard to envision them not winning their division.

Half Empty:
The Brady situation is not yet resolved, but if he misses the first four games, the team is facing a very serious problem. Their receiving corps is mediocre at best, and their passing game depends entirely on Brady’s icy precision. Without him they will struggle to move the ball and could get off to a very poor start. On the defensive side of the ball they are facing massive changes in scheme and personnel, losing their dominant secondary from last season and replacing them with essentially no one. Jones and free agent signee Jabaal Sheard are good pass rushers, but neither has shown the sort of consistent dominance needed on a defense with no back end. New England is good enough that they should make the playoffs no matter what, but it could be a fight to the end of the season.

Player to Watch: Jabaal Sheard, DE
I wrote about Sheard as my player to watch in Cleveland last year, and he failed to live up to expectations. But I’m going to keep riding this bandwagon until I’m the only one left. In Cleveland Sheard was a phenomenally talented pass rusher stuck in a scheme that didn’t fit his skills. That won’t be the case in New England, where Bill Belichick has shown consistent willingness to cater his scheme to the players he has. With Sheard and Chandler Jones coming off the edges, the Patriots pass rush will take pressure off of their vulnerable secondary.

Miami Dolphins
Half Full:
The offseason activity certainly makes this team fun to look at on paper. Adding Ndamukong Suh puts them in contention for the best defensive line in the league (though they still may be third best in this division), and their retooled receiving corps gives Ryan Tannehill weapons to work with as he enters his long term deal. Their running game came together as the year went along, and with a few more breaks going their way, they can put together enough wins to possibly steal the division.

Half Empty:
Okay, can anyone remember the last time a bunch of high profile offseason moves actually worked out? Reality isn’t as grim as common perception, but more often than not teams like the Dolphins fail to live up to expectations. They still haven’t fixed their offensive line or their secondary, and I am far from confident in Tannehill. The weapons he has are intriguing but unproven, and if he can’t get them the ball, the Dolphins could fall to pieces very quickly.

Player to Watch: Kenny Stills, WR
And here we come to the issue of getting them the ball. Stills has been one of the best deep targets in the league over the past two years, connecting at an almost ungodly success rate with Drew Brees in New Orleans. But Mike Wallace was also one of the best deep receivers before he got to Miami, and Stills is not as well rounded as a receiver as Wallace was. Tannehill is quietly terrible at throwing the ball deep, missing Wallace open deep on a regular basis last season. The Stills-Tannehill connection could open up their offense, but it could also doom them to the same mediocrity they faced last year.

Buffalo Bills
Half Full:
Buffalo certainly had an eventful offseason, adding more weapons to their offense than any other team in the league. Big additions like LeSean McCoy and Percy Harvin will add to the growth of talented young receivers like Robert Woods and Sammy Watkins to give them real firepower on offense for the first time in a while. They retained Jerry Hughes in free agency to keep their dangerous pass rush intact, and with Rex Ryan their defense can take the next step to carry this team into the playoffs for the first time since 1999.

Half Empty:
The quarterback situation will absolutely kill them. Even if everything else goes right, even if their defense stays dominant, McCoy revitalizes their running game, and Harvin turns into the player he once was, they still have the worst quarterback situation of anyone in the league. The idea that the three quarterbacks on their roster will combine to start sixteen games this year is laughable. Buffalo made some strides last year, but with their mess under center, they will regress into the same mediocrity they’ve seen every year for the past decade.

Player to Watch: Percy Harvin, WR
What the hell is Percy Harvin? Does anyone know at this point? In 2012 he was maybe the most dynamic player in the league before suffering a season ending injury. In 2013 he played only one game in the regular season due to injury, but he made several spectacular plays to help Seattle to the Super Bowl title. Last year was an utter disaster, leading him to sign this cheap, short term deal in Buffalo. The talent is still there, but so far he and his coaches have struggled to make use of it. If Buffalo has any hope of fielding a functioning offense, it’s going to need the creative, spectacular Harvin that we’ve only seen brief flashes of.

New York Jets
Half Full:
The quarterback situation will be a problem in all circumstances, but simple competence might be enough to claw them towards the playoffs. Their defensive line is stacked with talent like few others in the league (even with the possible loss of Sheldon Richardson), and their three free agent signings at cornerback give them possibly the deepest group in the NFL. On offense they have a pair of imposing weapons on the outside that should make life easier for their quarterback. Ryan Fitzpatrick isn’t the most reliable option, but he can do enough with the Jets to earn them a Wild Card berth.

Half Empty:
Everything needs to go right for the Jets to succeed, which is usually a bad sign for a team as dysfunctional as they are. They’ve already lost Geno Smith and possibly Richardson. Antonio Cromartie isn’t the most reliable cornerback, and Brandon Marshall showed signs of slowing down last season. Their running back group is still made up of players who are best used in a backup role, and if they can’t get a consistent running game established, they will have no hope of even sniffing the playoffs.

Player to Watch: Quinton Coples, DE/OLB
Coples is surprisingly off the radar for a former first round pick. Through three seasons he’s been a disappointment, a pass rusher who has collected only 16.5 career sacks. He struggled through Rex Ryan’s scheme for years, never quite finding a place where he fit in. He’s too big to play at linebacker as he has, too small to play as a lineman on the interior like the Jets like to use. He is a man without a position, which is why Todd Bowles is the perfect coach for him. Bowles excelled in Arizona with a defense made up of unusual talents, finding ways to utilize unique players like Deone Buchanon, Tyrann Mathieu, and Calais Campbell. Coples is right on the edge of being declared a bust, but if anyone can harness his potential, it would be Bowles.

Wednesday, August 12, 2015

NFL Positional Rankings



Even though training camps have started, we are still stuck in that dreadful period of time known as the NFL offseason. It’s been half a year since the last meaningful NFL game was played, and as a nation we are desperate for any sort of football coverage. The natural result of this is a tidal wave of player rankings, tiresome debates produced by just about every media organization in existence.

I’ve never been a fan of ranking football players. The skills involved are so varied, making comparisons almost impossible to do. You end up sidetracked by arguments over positional value, schematic fit, and other variables that are impossible to directly observe.

Comparing within a position is another matter. I don’t have a problem saying who I think is the best wide receiver in the league, or who the best quarterback is. And these comparisons can give us a sense of how much better an individual player is than the rest at his position.

This is how I’ve constructed the rankings below. For each position (not including kickers, punters, or long snappers because no one cares) I’ve gone through and selected the player I believe is the best at their position, then listed those (in no particular order) on the tier directly below them. The order I’ve placed them in is based on how much separation I believe there is between the player I’ve selected and this second tier. The best of the best are at the very top, while the positions at the bottom are the ones where I truly struggled to figure out who was the best in the league.

Hybrid D-Lineman: JJ Watt
Runners Up: Muhammad Wilkerson, Fletcher Cox, Calais Campbell, Michael Bennett
This is a position that has emerged over the past few years in the NFL, and I’m really not sure how to handle it. These players play multiple positions along the defensive line, from interior tackles to edge rushers. They aren’t necessarily there to go after the passer, but they do that well. Their job isn’t to occupy blockers and clog up the run, but they can do that too. There are very few players in the NFL even capable of doing this at an average level, and I may have listed them all above.

The important thing is, JJ Watt is the best in the league at doing one of the hardest things in the league. It might actually be fair to say that he plays a different position from every other player in the league, given the way he collects sacks while also stuffing up the middle. Watt is the best non-quarterback player in the league, and the gap between him and all other defenders is almost laughable at this point.

Tight End: Rob Gronkowski
Runners Up: Jimmy Graham, Jason Witten, Greg Olsen, Julius Thomas
We are at a strange period in the history of NFL tight ends. Tony Gonzalez is gone. Antonio Gates is not what he used to be. Athletic freaks like Jared Cook and Lardarius Green have failed to develop. We’re left with a bunch of good options, and one superstar who dominates when healthy.

The closest player to challenging Gronkowski is Jimmy Graham, and I’m not sure what to make of him. He had a miserable season in 2014, and I think it may be a sign of things to come. He’s failed to develop his physical tools, and without Brees throwing to him it’s fair to wonder if he’ll ever reach the peaks he saw early in his career. Gronkowki just continues to chug along, and as long as he’s healthy there really isn’t much debate for best tight end in the league.

Safety: Earl Thomas
Runners Up: Harrison Smith, Eric Weddle, Antoine Bethea, Devin McCourtey
The safety position has undergone an interesting transition over the past decade. There is no longer any tangible distinction between a strong and a free safety. The growth of the passing game has forced teams to move both their safeties out of the box into coverage, and there is no longer a place in the NFL for a hard hitting safety who can’t keep up with receivers (except potentially as an undersized linebacker).

The prototypical safety now is someone who can sit in a single deep zone and cover the middle of the field, and no one does that as well as Thomas. His speed and his instincts give him tremendous range, making him the most crucial piece of Seattle’s defensive success over the past three seasons. He’s also physical enough that he could probably step in for any of the players on the lower tier, while none of them could cover ground the way he does. Right now every safety in the NFL is jostling for second place behind Thomas, and it will probably remain that was for quite some time.
  
Offensive Guard: Marshal Yanda
Runners Up: Josh Sitton, Evan Mathis, Kyle Long
Yanda had a down year (along with the entire Ravens offense) in 2013, but he came roaring back in 2014. He is the best run blocker in football, and he paved the way for a reshuffled offensive line to turn Justin Forsett into one of the most productive running backs in the league. He isn’t as good a pass blocker as someone like Sitton, and in the right scheme Mathis can be a better player. But no one can do what Yanda does as consistently as Yanda does it.

Center: Alex Mack
Runners Up: Travis Frederick, Maurkice Pouncey, John Sullivan, Max Unger
Mack is overpaid, and he’s coming off an injury, so it’s understandable that some people are skeptical of him right now. But he has been the best center in the league over the past three seasons, and the loss of him last year played a major role in Cleveland’s collapse down the stretch. Mack will likely be back to his normal self this year, playing almost well enough to justify his ridiculous contract. Cleveland doesn’t have a lot going for them on offense, but they can at least rely on their offensive line.

Quarterback: Aaron Rodgers
Runners Up: Peyton Manning, Drew Brees, Tom Brady, Ben Roethlisberger, Andrew Luck
The quarterback position has been discussed to death, so I’m not going to say much here. Rodgers is the best in the league, and he’s got a reasonable lead over the next cluster. I don’t think Manning is done, but I also don’t think he’ll ever reach Rodgers’s level again. Brady and Brees are in a similar boat, and while Roethlisberger is coming off his best season, he just isn’t as talented as the others. The one player that has a chance to close the gap is Luck. I still have a lot of questions about Luck’s game, his decision making and his inconsistency, but at his best he is one of the few quarterbacks in the league who can make plays to challenge Rodgers. At some point I think he will be in the conversation for the best quarterback in the league, but for now Rodgers still has a sizeable advantage.

Wide Receiver: Antonio Brown
Runners Up: Dez Bryant, Julio Jones, AJ Green, Calvin Johnson, Jordy Nelson
People seem to have a weird reluctance to give Brown his due, largely because he doesn’t fit the physical profile of an elite wide receiver. He doesn’t have the size of any in the tier below him, or the strength, or the leaping ability. He doesn’t make spectacular leaping grabs, or break five tackles on the way to the endzone, or run away from coverage. All he does is produce.

2013-2014
Receptions
Yards
Touchdowns
Antonio Brown
239
3197
21
Dez Bryant
181
2553
29
Julio Jones
145
2173
8
AJ Green
167
2467
17
Calvin Johnson
155
2569
20
Jordy Nelson
183
2833
21

Brown has been the best receiver in the league for the past two seasons, and it’s not particularly close. He’s a model of consistency at a notoriously volatile position, and even though his physical tools don’t match up to other top receivers, he will continue to dominate thanks to his quickness and his spectacular route running ability.

Cornerback: Darrelle Revis
Runners Up: Richard Sherman, Patrick Peterson, Chris Harris, Desmond Trufant
Here it is, the position that’s been driven into the ground over the past three years. The others have cases to be made for being at the top of the position, but really this conversation comes down to two players. Revis and Sherman. Revis is the veteran technician, a superstar who just continues to perform at a high level even as he gets up there in years. Sherman is the young, boisterous challenger, the face of an elite defense who has proclaimed himself the best in the league. The narratives are overwhelming, to the point that I almost don’t want to address it.

In the end, I put Revis first for a simple reason: his scheme asks him to do more than Sherman’s. The Seahawks run a hybrid zone-man scheme that leaves Sherman with deep coverage, playing to his strengths while not asking him to keep up with quick moving receivers underneath. Revis plays strictly man, mirroring the opposing receiver in a way Sherman would struggle to do.

Linebacker: Luke Keuchly
Runners Up: Lavonte David, Bobby Wagner, Navarro Bowman, DeAndre Levy
With the retirement of Patrick Willis, the recurring injuries to Sean Lee, and the general movement of teams away from off the ball linebackers, this position has become one of the more barren in the league. Most linebackers are trained to stuff the run and struggle against the pass, and these days they often play fewer snaps than a third cornerback. The top linebackers are the ones who can stay on the field for all three downs, who can cover the pass as well as they stop the run.

I think Keuchly is a bit overrated, but he is still the best at this weak position. Players like David and Levy (and his own teammate Thomas Davis) are better in coverage, and both Wagner and Bowman are better against the run. But Keuchly excels by doing everything at an extremely high level. There are no weaknesses in his game, and even though I don’t think he’ll ever again reach the heights of his Defensive Player of the Year second season, he’ll be a top notch inside linebacker for the rest of his career.

Offensive Tackle: Joe Thomas
Runners Up: Tyron Smith, Jason Peters, Andrew Whitworth
Thomas probably wasn’t the best offensive tackle in the league last season, or even the season before that. At their peaks Smith, Peters, and Whitworth all dominate in a way Thomas doesn't. But offensive tackle is a position that demands consistency, and no one has been more consistent than Thomas. He’s been named to the Pro Bowl every year he’s been in the league, and he’s been an All Pro every season but his first. Because he plays in Cleveland and plays on the line, most people seem to ignore him. But looking at his résumé, it’s hard not to start to wonder if he may be putting himself in the conversation for the greatest to ever play the position.

Edge Rusher: Von Miller
Runners Up: Justin Houston, Robert Quinn, Elvis Dumervil, Clay Matthews
These players live in the shadow of JJ Watt, but for today I’m going to allow them a chance to be in their own category. They play exclusively on the edge, and their primary responsibility is to rush the passer. Houston quietly had one of the greatest pass rushing seasons of all time last year, racking up 22 sacks while being overshadowed by Watt’s inhuman dominance. I strongly considered putting him at the top of this category, but he lost a narrow race to his AFC West rival.

Miller has kind of gotten lost in the shuffle over the past few years. He was the first defensive player taken in the incredible 2011 draft class, and he went on to win a deserved Defensive Rookie of the Year. After that, though, things kind of fell apart. He was suspended for a failed drug test, and then he suffered a torn ACL. He’s been overshadowed both by his draftmate Watt and his teammate Peyton Manning. And through it all, he has simply been one of the best players in the league against the run and the pass. At this point it might actually be fair to call him underrated, since he’s probably the second best defensive player in the league.

Defensive Tackle: Ndamukong Suh
Runners Up: Gerald McCoy, Aaron Donald, Marcell Dareus
Suh wins almost by default. McCoy is better when he’s healthy, but he has too many injury problems. Donald was better last year, and I think he’ll probably pass him soon. But for now I have to rank Suh as the best defensive tackle in the league. He’s been a great player since he was drafted, a force against both the run and the pass, and he is probably worth every penny the Dolphins paid him this offseason. Suh has been the consensus best defensive tackle since he came into the league, but it is a lot closer than most people realize, and his run may be coming to an end.

Running Back: Adrian Peterson
Runners Up: Jamaal Charles, LeSean McCoy, Marshawn Lynch, LeVeon Bell, DeMarco Murray
Running back is weird and hard to handle. The two best runners in the league last year were Bell and Murray, but I have a hard time ranking either of them first based on one productive year. Charles has been steady for a while, but he’s never produced at the same volume as some of the others. McCoy seems to disappoint every other year, and while Lynch is consistent, I don’t think he has ever been the best back in the league.

Call me a homer, but I made a close decision to go with Peterson. He barely played last year for off the field reasons, and he’s nearing the point where most running backs break down. But he’s been the best running back in the league since he was drafted, and until we see clear evidence that his performance falling off, I’m going to stick to my guns. But I’d have no problem with anyone calling any of these other backs the best in the league, which is why this position finds itself at the bottom of the list.