Friday, April 13, 2018

2018 Draft Prospects: Offensive Linemen


Offensive line play in the NFL sucks right now, and it isn’t getting better particularly quickly. After a weak class last year, things are only mildly looking up in 2018. This is an excellent class up the middle, but the tackles remain dreadful, and trying to protect the edges of the line is going to remain a challenge for years ahead.

Quenton Nelson, G – Notre Dame

Image result for quenton nelson pancake
Nelson looks like what you would get if you tried to design a perfect guard. He’s big, and he’s strong, and he’s surprisingly mobile, light on his feet and able to cover a lot of ground as a blocker. He excels pulling out into space as a lead blocker, especially once he gets turned upfield and can set his sights on a smaller linebacker or defensive back. He has the sort of nasty streak that guards are known for, and he enjoys driving defenders into the ground even if they’re no longer relevant to the play.

Nelson’s physical tools set him apart, but he has more working for him than just that. He’s an incredibly smart player, able to diagnose and recognize late developing blitzes on the fly. When there’s a man ahead of him, he is perfectly comfortable dancing side to side or absorbing a bull rush. When he has no one to block he is always looking for work, and more often than not he finds it. He plays aggressive, attacking off the line and searching for someone to hit as the play develops.

The biggest hole in Nelson’s game is his hand usage. He gets pretty sloppy sometimes, both as a downhill run blocker and a dropback pass blocker. On some plays he doesn’t bother to use his hands at all, and on others he makes poor use of them, striking off target and sliding away from the defender. He can knock himself off balance sometimes, and even though he has above average recovery ability he isn’t always able to make the play.

Nelson got by in college by being bigger and stronger than everyone else he faced. But that won’t work in the NFL, at least not right away. Defensive tackles are able to get into his chest, and he won’t be able to hold his ground against professional big men like he did collegiate ones. He’ll be a good starter from day one, and if he can fix his technique he can be much better than that down the road. But I still don’t buy the top ten hype he is receiving, and I think he’d be better suited somewhere in the middle of the first round.

Billy Price, C – Ohio State
Image result for billy price
When the actual draft rolls around, Price will likely go quite a bit lower than he should based on his tape. This is largely due to a torn pectoral he suffered at the Combine, which will reportedly keep him off the field right up to the beginning of training camp. In a year with a deep interior offensive line class this will likely be enough to convince teams to pass on him. But I am not going to knock him down my board because of it. I don’t know how to properly measure this sort of risk factor, and to try to penalize him for it with my limited knowledge of medicine and his specific circumstance would be unfair. I will evaluate Price with the same criteria I use for all the other players, and that criteria tells me he is worth a mid first round selection.

Price’s greatest strength is his hand usage. He has a phenomenal punch that is almost always perfectly timed and perfectly aimed, striking a defender high on his shoulders to knock him off his rush. In the passing game Price can absorb contact and anchor into the ground, and in the rushing game he can win control of a defender’s upper body. His hands latch on and do not let go, and on down blocks he does a fine job swinging his hips around to prevent a defender from crossing his face.

My biggest concerns about Price are athleticism, concerns that we were unable to confirm or refute after he was injured at the Combine. On film he appears to struggle when he has to move laterally, taking a long time whenever he is asked to pull around as a lead blocker. He doesn’t have the speed to pull regularly in the NFL, and he isn’t going to be able to offer any help outside the tackle box. His athleticism also causes issues when he has to react quickly to stunts or late pressure, as he has issues moving his feet to pick up a late rusher.

Price has good strength in his upper body, but he is going to need to develop more power from the waist down. He doesn’t push defenders around in the running game, and if they play him head up he has trouble taking advantage of his upper body leverage to swing them around and seal off the hole. The truth is, he likely isn’t ever going to be someone who physically dominates the opponent, and that limits his ceiling enough to knock him down despite being one of the cleanest technicians in the draft.

Will Hernandez, G – UTEP
Image result for will hernandez
Hernandez is another extremely big and extremely strong interior line prospect. At the Combine he weighed 327 pounds and did 37 reps on the bench press, a pair of impressive numbers that confirmed what I saw on tape. Hernandez is a bulldozer in the running game and a brick wall in the passing game, and in the right scheme he can be a high level contributor.

Movement is Hernandez’s biggest weakness, though he’s better in space than you would expect from someone his size. He has decent agility from side to side, and he can get even better as he works on his balance and technique going forward. But right now he looks clumsy whenever he tries to pull, and he struggles to move to the second level to pick up linebackers in space. Any scheme that asks him to move around too much will not be making the best use of him, and that lack of versatility should knock him down to the very end of the first round.

Even in his comfort zone, Hernandez still has quite a bit to work on. He has strong hands when he engages and locks on, and he can twist a defender’s upper body and move his feet to seal off a running lane. But at times he will miss his target with his punches, getting too wide and exposing his chest. His feet aren’t quick enough to instantly mirror defenders, and while his upper body strength is enough to give him time to catch up, it does leave him vulnerable to occasional holding penalties. In general I would like to see him be more aggressive, leading with a powerful punch rather than catching defenders and keeping his feet moving after contact to get movement down the field. He’s a bit of a development project, and I’m not sure if he’s ready to start as a rookie, but there is a decently high ceiling if he’s put into a position that utilizes his strengths and minimizes his weaknesses.

Orlando Brown, T – Oklahoma
Image result for orlando brown jr oklahoma
Brown may be the most difficult prospect I’ve ever had to rank, because he is the player who most directly challenges me on how I weigh tape versus athletic ability. If I was just ranking him based on what he does on the field, I’d have him as a mid first round pick, potentially even in the top ten. If I was ranking him just based on what he did at the Combine, I don’t think he’d be draftable.

Even if you aren’t a fan of the Combine, we have to acknowledge what Brown did there. He had quite possibly the worst performance any player at any position has ever had. He ranked in the first percentile in the forty yard dash, vertical jump, broad jump, 20 yard shuttle, and bench press. He put up numbers that don’t seem physically possible. How does someone who weighs 345 pounds only get 13 reps benching 225? How does someone have less than 20 inches in the vertical? When he gets drafted he will be the worst athlete to ever be drafted in the NFL, and it won’t be particularly close.

And the thing is, it’s not like we can’t see his questionable athleticism on the field. He moves better than his numbers indicate, but he still looks slow when asked to pull to the other side of the line or cut back downhill in response to an inside move. But he often didn’t have to move much, as his size allowed him to occupy so much more space than even a normal offensive tackle. He’s so big that he can’t be bull rushed, and his arms are so long that it takes forever to run around him. And despite his bench press failures he showed an impressive punch on the field, able to stop a pass rusher in his tracks and force him wide up the field.

I don’t know what to make of Brown at all. At times he can be a dominant force against the run, collapsing an entire side of the line on a down block. And he has good enough technique in pass protection to make up for shaky mobility that sometimes exposes him on inside moves. But the simple fact is that there’s no record of a player this unathletic succeeding in the NFL. The issues revealed at the Combine raise questions about both his upside and his risk of becoming a bust, and I think they should be enough to drop him into the second round.


Mike McGlinchey, T – Notre Dame
Image result for mike mcglinchey
No matter what happens in front of him, McGlinchey doesn’t panic. His play in and play out consistency is remarkable, as he looks exactly the same on almost every snap of the ball. He gets where he wants to go off the snap, and he keeps his feet chapping beneath him, ready to react to whatever move the defender throws his way. This translates into excellent recovery ability, as he never allows himself to get off balance is always ready to react in any direction. He is also able to absorb contact without surrendering much ground, chopping his feet to regain his balance and then anchoring once his base is firm.

McGlinchey’s style in his pass sets is a bit different than most of the other tackles I’ve scouted. Most tackles go for a single powerful punch, hoping to disrupt the pass rusher and then latch on. McGlinchey doesn’t have much power on his punch, but this allows him to conserve his balance, and to remain in position to attack in response to whatever the pass rusher does next. He can stagger an incoming defender with a series of quicker, smaller punches that allow him to react on the fly and handle advanced counter moves.

I’m not entirely convinced this style will translate to the NFL. Without an effective punch he will need to cover a lot of ground laterally to close off the edge, and while he is a perfectly capable athlete nothing he’s done suggests he is at that level. In college he struggled with pass rushers who had both the speed to get outside his frame and the power to push through his weak thrusts, the sort of players he will face regularly in the NFL.

McGlinchey could probably be an impact starter right away, but he has quite a bit of work to do to become anything more than just an average player. I could definitely see that development happening to make him a real force on the outside, but we’re likely talking two to three years down the road. I don’t think that kind of gamble is worth a first round pick, but I’d be willing to take a chance on my second go around.


Brian O’Neill, T – Pittsburgh
Image result for brian o'neill pitt
O’Neill is a former tight end, and he looks like it on the field, with all the positive and negative connotations that carries. He is a sensational athlete, smooth in every movement he makes, and he is extremely raw as an offensive lineman. The first couple steps of his pass set are gorgeous, as he drops exactly where he needs to be with quick feet and impeccable balance. And if the pass rusher does exactly what he expects, he is in perfect position to handle him, with an effective punch that will stop his rush and give O’Neill the edge for the rest of the play.

Problems arise when things don’t go exactly as O’Neill expects them to. He doesn’t know how to read the player across from him, and he is consistently beaten by anything more complex than a speed rush. He gives up his chest too easily, and he can get blown backwards in both the run and the passing game. His pass set is mechanical, and he isn’t in position to react back down if the pass rusher cuts across his face. And the moment things start breaking down, he forgets all his fundamentals, letting his arms drop to his sides and giving the defensive player open lanes to the ball carrier.

Athletic ability obviously gives O’Neill upside, but I’m not sure just how much he actually has. He has a long way to go to become a reliable starting caliber tackle, and there are parts of his game that may always be lacking. He doesn’t get a lot of push in the running game, and he doesn’t really latch on with his hands. Defenders are able to slip away from him after initial contact, and he doesn’t quite have the quick feet to shuffle away from them. I think that even if everything breaks right for him he still won’t be an elite NFL tackle, and he is far enough away from simple competence that this upside isn’t enough to push him higher than the second round.

Isaiah Wynn, G – Georgia
Image result for isaiah wynn
Wynn played both guard and tackle in college, but a limited physical skillset will likely constrain him to the inside in the NFL. He isn’t particularly big at only 6-3, and he struggles some with agility in space. This latter part will be an issue at guard as well, where he will struggle to counter some of the quicker interior pass rushers in the league. But he’s strong enough with his upper body that he can disrupt their paths to the quarterback as long as he has a tighter space to work in.

Wynn’s strength is in the running game, where his technique and his power combine to offset most of his other issues. He fires aggressively downhill and delivers a powerful punch, capable of knocking a defender off balance so he can drive him into the ground five yards downfield. His lack of quickness causes problems on aggressive reach blocks, but when he starts from an advantage he does a very good job of attacking the correct shoulder and using his leverage to swing his hips around and seal a defender off from the hole.

If there’s one thing that concerns me most about Wynn’s move to the inside, it’s his hands. He has a good punch, but after the initial contact he generally loses more often than he wins. He doesn’t latch on to the guy he’s blocking, and he can be beaten by quick-twitch counter moves. He will also occasionally surrender his chest, leaving himself vulnerable to being driven backwards. I’m not sure how correctible these issues are in the NFL, and I don’t think he’ll ever be more than an average guard.

Connor Williams, T – Texas
Image result for connor williams texas
Williams is a good athlete who never really figured out how to use that athleticism in college. He is light on his feet and quick shuffling side to side, but just getting to the right spot is only half the battle. Once he’s completed his drop, Williams doesn’t really do anything to help contain the guy he’s supposed to block.

The key to good pass protection is the punch, and Williams doesn’t have one. He’ll attempt to strike out at the opposing rusher, but more often than not it’s like he isn’t doing anything. Rushers have no trouble blowing through his week armed blows, and most can get inside his chest where his slender frame is easily shoved backwards. Even when he tries to stay in front of his opponent he struggles to stay square, and it takes just one hand on his shoulder to turn his hips and open up a lane.

His athletic potential is intriguing, but I don’t see any other reason to care about Williams. His agility doesn’t translate to the running game, where he has trouble blocking anyone outside his frame. And while I think he has some ability to add weight without losing much speed, I don’t think it will make much difference. Some have suggested that he may be better suited at guard in the NFL, but that transition doesn’t seem to me like it would play to his strengths. He certainly isn’t ready to play any position along the line right now, and there’s no reason to believe his potential to develop into a starter is worth more than a third round pick.

Tuesday, April 10, 2018

2018 Draft Prospects: Defensive Interior


Most people still use the traditional defensive position designations of defensive tackle, defensive end, inside linebacker, and outside linebacker. That’s the way the league has worked for most of its history, and those terms have stuck around even though they no longer describe the way players are grouped.

I prefer to go with a more modern grouping. Last week I looked at “off ball linebackers” which encompass players who primarily line up in the box back away from the line. Next week I’ll get around to the “edge” defenders, the pass rushers that are either called defensive ends or outside linebackers based almost entirely on whether they rush from a 2 or a 3 point stance.

Today I’m focusing on “defensive interior”. Some of these players will be called defensive tackles, some defensive ends. Whatever they’re called, they will spend the majority of their snaps playing between the tackles on the line of scrimmage, trying to either stack up the middle or penetrate into the backfield.

Vita Vea, Washington
Image result for vita vea
The discussion surrounding Vea isn’t as much about him as it is about the value of the position he plays. There is no doubt that he is a spectacular and rare talent. Standing 6-4 and weighing an absurd 347 pounds, he moves in a way that someone that size really shouldn’t. He’s light on his feet, and he is insanely strong, able to swallow offensive linemen whole and walk them five or six yards deep in the backfield. He is the ultimate run stuffing nose tackle, a player who can absorb double teams and can play two gaps against single blockers, with the strength to stop a running back with a single arm if he comes within reach.

The problem is that the league is trending away from these big, space eating tackles. Gone are the days when you could just shrug your shoulders at a player on the defensive interior who doesn’t get after the quarterback. Pass rush is crucial at every position along the defensive line, and it’s hard to justify selecting a tackle in the first round who can’t wreak havoc in the passing game.

There are mixed opinions on how much Vea brings as a pass rusher, largely because he was so inconsistent in that role in college. He does a good job leading with his hands to strike into the opposing lineman’s chest, and once he’s engaged he can toss a blocker aside with a single hand or walk him deep into the backfield. He struggles to finish plays once he’s back there, but he gets enough push to disrupt the quarterback and give the other rushers opportunity to grab a sack.

Vea is never going to be a ten sack a year guy, but I think he has more pass rush potential than he showed in college. Washington ran a lot of complex blitzes, and more often than not his job was to just eat up blockers while their linebackers looped in. When he was given opportunities in clear passing situations, he was able to fire into a gap and use his strength to push through the arms of the blocker in front of him. Any small gap became a wide open rushing lane, and if he’s freed to do more of that in the NFL, he can be a productive pass rushing threat. That’s the only real question with him, and while there is still some risk that it doesn’t develop as I think it will, I still think he’s worth a pick in the upper half of the first round.

Harrison Phillips, Stanford
 Image result for harrison phillips
Lower body strength is crucial to playing the defensive tackle position, but Phillips shows the value of upper body strength as well. Most people roll their eyes at the bench press test at the Combine, but an astonishing 42 reps from Phillips confirms what is often seen on the field. He is incredibly strong in his upper body, and that strength allows him to consistently win the handfighting that occurs in the trenches. When single blocked he almost always ends up controlling the opposing lineman’s chest, allowing him to hold his ground and to make plays in the gaps on either side as the ball comes near him.

Phillips needs to do more to win after he has established position over the opposing player. He doesn’t often shed to truly free himself up, and his lateral range is limited. He leaves himself vulnerable to being cleaned up from the side, and occasionally he has trouble keeping himself square to prevent being sealed off from a specific gap. At times he can be slow out of his stance, and he usually engages on the wrong side of the line of scrimmage, often coming straight up rather than forward and playing with his pad level too high.

I have concerns about Phillips’s versatility and upside, though his athletic profile is intriguing. He is very quick in tight spaces, and he can win by leaping across a lineman’s face and swimming over top of him. But despite a very good performance in the three cone drill, flexibility looks like a concern on the field. He struggles to bend through contact to make a play, and he can be washed out of his rushing lane too easily. The foundation of a good player is there, but it will take some work to reach what he’s capable of, and I’m concerned enough about his weaknesses on the field that I wouldn’t take him until the end of the first round.

Maurice Hurst, Michigan
Image result for maurice hurst
Hurst wins off the snap, or he doesn’t win at all. He has one of the quickest getoffs I’ve seen, firing out low and fast and knifing into the gaps between the opposing offensive linemen. He almost always makes contact on the offensive side of the line of scrimmage, and the momentum of his initial burst can power him trough the arms of the opposing linemen into the backfield to make a splash tackle for a loss.

That’s what happens when everything goes right. Far more frequently, his speed off the line isn’t enough to prevent the opposing lineman from stepping into his path. And when that happens, the play is essentially over for Hurst. He has no counter moves, and he really doesn’t use his hands at all. His almost always makes contact leading with his shoulder or, strangely, his back. At times he’ll flip completely around and end up buried in an ineffective pile as the ball races in the opposite direction.

But man, that getoff is hard to ignore. Counter moves and hand usage are tools that can be developed in the NFL, and Hurst could potentially be effective with them if he’s given time and patience to grow. Size will always be a concern—he tested in the 20th percentile or lower for every size measurement before having to leave the Combine due to a (since cleared) medical red flag—and he is a liability more often than an asset in the running game. But he has the ability to generate big plays and sacks like few others in this class, and I would consider grabbing him late in the first round.

Taven Bryan, Florida
Image result for taven bryan
Bryan is the other side of the coin from Vea. Weighing only 291 pounds, he would have been considered too small to play regularly on the inside in the past, but the changes to the game recently have made smaller, quicker defensive tackles increasingly valuable. Bryan specializes in shooting through a gap into the backfield. He is almost always the first player moving off the snap, and he wrecks the angles linemen take to try to block him.

Size does occasionally present an issue for Bryan. He’s tall, but his arms aren’t very long, and he struggles to get consistent separation from the lineman blocking him. He can get a good push off his initial burst, but once his momentum peters out he doesn’t have the strength to walk a blocker backwards. He can get pushed around some himself, and he has issues bending through contact to make plays once he’s in the backfield.

As quick as he is off the ball, I don’t see enough else in Bryan’s game to make him worth more than a late first round pick. He doesn’t play with great awareness, often overrunning ball carriers in the backfield. He covers a lot of ground side to side and can make plays outside the tackle box, but he is vulnerable when the ball comes straight at him. I don’t see enough consistency to make me think the splashes are worth the downsides, and even with his tremendous athleticism I don’t think his ceiling is all that high.

Da’Ron Payne, Alabama
Image result for da'ron payne
Payne has moments of brilliance where he looks unstoppable, and on a highlight reel it would be hard not to argue that he is a high first round talent. At times he seems unblockable, with a wide variety of moves that let him break free of contact and win leverage into the backfield. His best move is a swim across the face of the opposing lineman, but he also has the strength to grab and yank the blocker out of his path and the quickness to shoot through a gap off the snap.

Payne’s flashes are remarkable, but there are plenty of reasons to worry about if they can ever be more than just flashes. As good as his moves are, they are most effective as counter moves, and against NFL quality talent and scouting he’s going to need something more. If he tries a swim move when the opposing blocker is expecting it, he will be doing nothing more than surrendering his chest to get blown backwards from the line (something that happened regularly in college as well). He isn’t strong enough or quick enough to win play after play, and when he gets beaten in the handfighting game things usually get pretty ugly.

There are other issues with Payne’s game, mostly around his struggles to finish plays once he’s in the backfield. He plays high and doesn’t have much bend, and even when he gets past a blocker he can find himself shoved from behind out of the play. He tested as a below average athlete, and though I thought he looked better than that on the field, he never looked like someone playing at a different speed than everyone else. I think he can be a solid starter in the NFL, but you will need players and a scheme around him to compensate for his weaknesses, and he isn’t the sort of foundational player you would spend a first round selection to take.

Derrick Nnadi, Florida State
Image result for derrick nnadi
Nnadi is fairly good in the first second after the snap. He comes off the ball quickly and engages with his hands on the other side of the line, usually winning into the chest of the opposing lineman. He isn’t quick enough to penetrate into gaps, but he can drive linemen a couple yards deep into the backfield off his initial lunge.

Nnadi’s hands are good off the snap of the ball, and then they just stop. He doesn’t bother to disengage, and though he’s good at finishing through contact, he doesn’t make any tackles outside of arm’s reach. And at times after his initial burst he will end up standing straight up, surrendering his chest and allowing the offensive lineman to regain the advantage. He can get pushed backwards at the point of attack, and he can occasionally leave gaps wide open in the running game.

Inconsistent against the run, Nnadi is even worse as a pass rusher. He has the strength to collapse the pocket in front of the quarterback, but instead of using it he usually just tries to run around the opposing lineman. He had an absolutely abysmal Combine, and his lack of athletic ability makes it easy for blockers to wash him out of his rushing lane, leaving the quarterback plenty of space to step up. Outside of his size and some promising strength, I really don’t see anything to like about Nnadi, and I wouldn’t take him before the fourth round.